Chapter Five: Easing Into the Stretch
Carlton and Michelle
December had been kinder. Work still pressed, but not with the crushing weight of November. Michelle had finally managed to train up two new hires, and for the first time in weeks, her calendar wasn’t gasping for air. Carlton’s schedule lined up in its own weird way—four games at home, no flights, no hotel beds. Just the city, his place or hers, and more time together than they’d had since this whole thing began.
He’d decided to host a small get-together. Nothing fancy. Just Malik, a couple of teammates, and a few close friends. Michelle didn’t mind. She’d seen her family over Thanksgiving, filled her tank with the noisy warmth of nieces and nephews. Tonight, she was content to stay in Carlton’s orbit.
Malik had already stolen the spotlight within ten minutes of arrival. He reenacted a play from practice. Badly. Complete with falling over Carlton’s ottoman in slow motion.
The room howled. Michelle nearly did a spit take, laughing, until Carlton tossed a cushion at him and said, “Bro, stop embarrassing me in my own house.”
“No promises,” Malik replied, bowing like he’d just finished a Broadway show.
The night rolled like that. Easy laughter, food disappearing from trays faster than it could be refilled, the low hum of music under conversations. Michelle sat back at one point, glass in hand, watching Carlton move around the room. He wasn’t putting on a show. He didn’t have to. He was just… himself. And she liked him here just as much as she liked him on the court or in the clinic. Maybe more.
When everyone left and the last door clicked shut, the quiet felt heavier, but in a good way. Michelle stacked plates while Carlton gathered cups. They fell into rhythm, clearing the counters with the kind of silent teamwork that didn’t need words.
Until she noticed it.
He shifted, just slightly, carrying dishes to the sink. The set of his shoulders was off. The gait wasn’t the smooth glide she knew; it caught, almost imperceptibly, on his left side.
“Carlton,” she said softly.
He didn’t turn. “Hmm?”
“What’s going on with your back?”
“I’m fine.” Too quick. Too dismissive.
She set her glass down with a deliberate clink and moved before he could escape again. He turned to put something in the sink, but she was already there, catching him between the island and the counter. He blinked. Caught. Nowhere to go.
“Carlton,” she repeated. “Talk to me. You’re walking like a man a half step into retirement,” she joked.
“Come on, Michelle. Don’t do that,” he said, walking around her.
“Carlton.”
For a second, he held her gaze like he was deciding whether to push past it. Then he sighed, rubbing a hand over his jaw. “I wanted tonight to be perfect. I didn’t want you to worry about anything. But I tweaked my back earlier this week, and it’s been… lingering.” He looked down, jaw tight. “I’ve been stressed, honestly. I don’t need anymore time on the bench. I don’t-“, he sighed. “I don’t want the only time I see you to be on somebody’s table. Not now.”
Her chest softened, not at his words but at the frustration behind them. She leaned back against the counter, keeping him close. His height, his presence—right there, just a breath away.
“I think I know what this is and I don’t think it’s just about basketball,” she said slowly, carefully. “I’ve only heard about this technique, but I’ve never really been able to use it. But if you trust me, I’d like to try.”
He raised a brow, half-skeptical, half-intrigued. “What kind of technique?”
“The good kind.” A small smile tugged at her lips. “But you have to let me lead.”
He hesitated, searching her eyes. Then, after a sigh, he gave a short nod. “I trust you.”
She held out her hand. He took it without hesitation, large palm swallowing hers, and she pulled him closer until the air between them was thin. Her other hand lifted, brushing his shirt hem. “May I?” she whispered.
His voice was low, rough. “Yeah.”
Her fingers slid beneath the fabric, warm against his skin, and he flinched at the first contact—more from surprise than pain. Her hands skimmed his back, finding the lines of muscle she knew too well, tracing until she reached the knot, tight and stubborn. He winced. She pressed gently. “Here?”
He exhaled. “There.”
“Okay,” she whispered. “Deep breath.”
He obeyed, closing his eyes. She felt the rise of his chest under her hands. And as his lungs emptied, she lifted on her toes, leaned in, and brushed a soft kiss against his lips.
“I love you, too,” she breathed, timing the words with the release. Her voice was steady, her heart anything but. “Now let that settle in.”
His eyes flew open, stunned. For a second, he just stared, like he wasn’t sure if she meant it or if he’d imagined it. Then he moved, fast, sure, closing the space, his mouth on hers again, deeper this time. The kiss said everything he hadn’t been able to put into sentences these past months, all the restraint burning away in one rush.
Michelle’s fingers curled into his back, holding him close, not as his PT, not as the one who kept him from injury, but as the woman who loved him. And for the first time, she let herself believe he might really love her too.
Michelle pulled away first, breath shaky. Her body was doing things she hadn’t felt in years, and it scared her how much she didn’t want it to stop. She put a hand on his chest, pushing just enough space to breathe.
“It’s hot,” she admitted. “We can’t.”
Carlton blinked. “We can’t?”
“Not like that.” She started pacing the living room, arms crossed tight like that might keep her from combusting.
He tilted his head, half amused. “Yeah. No. That was a lot.”
“Yeah.” She pointed at him like it was his fault. “We talked about that.”
He frowned. “We did?”
“Yeah, we didn’t want to go there.”
He laughed, incredulous. “We talked about that?!”
Michelle bent over, hands on her knees, breathing hard like she’d just finished suicides. “Carlton, I love you, but I don’t know if I have the self-control to do that again.”
That broke him. He grinned wide and charged around the couch. There was nothing wrong with his back now! She tried to dart the other way, but he was quicker, catching her at the edge.
“Carlton—” she started, but her laughter gave her away. They both fell on the couch.
He kissed her again. She let him. Slower this time. Deeper. Intentional in a way that made her toes curl. It threatened more, promised more, but stopped right at the edge.
When he finally pulled back, both of them were breathless again.
“Okay,” he said, voice low but steady. “I agree.”
She leaned her forehead against his chest, still catching her breath. “Good. Because that was… yeah.”
“Yeah,” he echoed, smiling against her hair.
They let it hang there before moving back into the kitchen. He grabbed the stray cups, she loaded plates into the dishwasher. It felt oddly domestic; two people tidying up after a night that had been bigger than both of them.
When the counters were finally clear, she reached for her coat. “I should go.”
“You’re not leaving,” he said flatly, already hanging the dish towel back on the oven handle.
“Carlton—”
“Michelle, it’s past midnight,” he cut in. He stepped toward the window, nodding at the flakes falling thick and slow under the streetlight. “It’s snowing. I’m not letting you drive in that.”
Her mouth opened, ready to argue, but the sight of snow softening the world outside made her pause.
He turned back to her, tone gentler now. “Stay. I’ll take the couch.”
Her eyes flicked up at him, searching, soft. “You don’t have to—”
“I do,” he said simply. “You’ll sleep better knowing it.”
Something in her eased at that. She slipped out of her coat and draped it over a chair. “Okay,” she whispered, almost surprised at herself.
He smiled, quiet and relieved. “Good.”
The TV hummed low in the background as they settled. She curled up in the bed with a blanket he grabbed, still warm from the dryer. He lingered a little too long before heading to the couch, watching her settle in with that same half-smile he got when the game was already won.
For the first time in months, Michelle let herself rest without fighting it.
And for the first time in years, Carlton didn’t mind giving up his bed.
